The irony of PG Medical Training in India by Dr Chiranjeevi Nayak

2 mn read
This post was originally published on facebook group NEET PG and DNB 2018 Counselling Aid and Update by Dr Chiranjeevi Nayak . It very well describes the unheard demand of lakhs of PG aspirants. The author has highlighted funny and illogical ironies of Indian medical education system and why most Indian doctors are going to grow weaker clinically in the coming years. 


Long post. Bear with me.

After completing MBBS, most of us want to get into PG.  Whoever says just a MBBS degree is enough is joking. The kind of training we receive in MBBS is no where sufficient. (I did not know ACLS protocol or most emergency medicine protocols, till I studied them seriously for PG)

Now coming to the entrance exam itself, NBE changes the pattern every year. No clinical questions at all! How does knowing about HaraKiri and the height a mosquito can fly to, help me in becoming a good doctor. Maybe it increases your GK. Why cant we have a USMLE based paper. Two exams, one part containing first 2 year subjects, conducted on one sunday and the next part next sunday having next 2 year subjects. With more clinical and decision making questions.

But why take 1 month to declare results in the age of lightning fast Google search results?

Next, the dilemma with different courses. DNB, MD/MS and Diploma. Why have Diploma at all? Whats the point? Why cant it be converted to MD. And DNB has low passing rate but is considered clinically a better degree? So why does everyone prefer MD? Because you can pass easily? Then why do most MDs do DNB post MD? Also, why are there MD courses in non clinicals in PG? Why are non clinical taught by doctors? (In developed countries, its usually taught by MSC PhD candidates who are more research and teaching oriented) Why not a nationalized degree? Why not have only clinical PG seats?

Why doesnt the government keep equal number of seats in PG and UG. Why most PG seats in private colleges? America has more PG seats than UG seats. Also the training period being only 3 years for all MD courses? Just 3 years for Ortho and OBG? Every subject should be as long as the subjects course content and training requirement. (America has 5 year for OBG, 4 for Anesthesia etc) And why not Government sponsered PG course? Why ask the students to pay huge fees in private colleges? Rather they should be paid a stipend.

Reservations! (Im a category student) Do we require it in Post Graduation? UG accepted. But specialty PG? Or at least Category students should be made to do extra rural service?

Coaching institutes? I think it is more profitable in opening a coaching institute than being a super specialist.

There are many more such problems. But be determined guys. If not this time, certainly next time. Keep working hard. You will succeed.

RANT OVER.
Dr Chiranjeevi Nayak


Check out similar posts

DISPARITIES IN THE SALARY OF RESIDENT DOCTORS IN INDIA

”MYTHS AND FACTS ABOUT MEDICAL PROFESSION”
https://worldsurgeryforum.net/2017/11/myths-and-facts-about-medical-profession.html

DRACONIAN GOVERNMENT BONDS IN INDIA FOR GOVERNMENT MEDICAL SUPER SPECIALTY SEATS: 10 YEARS OR RS 2 CRORE!
https://worldsurgeryforum.net/2017/10/draconian-government-bonds-for.html

Don’t miss these high yield posts and exam guidance by World Surgery Forum. Subscribe Now!

* indicates required

One thought on

The irony of PG Medical Training in India by Dr Chiranjeevi Nayak

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Explore More Surgery Topics You Like

Best Surgery Books

BEST BOOKS FOR MRCS PART A
MRCS Part A: Essential Revision Notes: Book 1
MRCS Part A: Essential Revision Notes: Book 2

MRCS Practice Papers Part A: Paper 1 SBAs

MRCS Practice Papers Part A: Paper 2 EMQs

Rush University Medical Center Review of Surgery

Bailey & Love Companion Guide Mcqs & Emqs In Surgery

SBA MCQs and EMQs for the MRCS Part A Pack: 2

Basic Science for the MRCS: A revision guide for surgical trainees

Oxford Handbook of Clinical Surgery

Get Through MRCS Part A: SBAs

Mrcs Module 2016 Question With Explanations For Mrcs The Best Question Series

EMQs and Data Interpretation Questions in Surgery

BEST BOOKS FOR MRCS PART B

DrExam Part B MRCS OSCE Revision Guide: Book 1

DrExam Part B MRCS OSCE Revision Guide: Book 2

OSCEs for the MRCS Part B: A Bailey & Love Revision Guide

Succeeding in the MRCS Part B Exam: Essential revision notes for the OSCE format

Get Through MRCS: Anatomy 2E

Clinical Anatomy: Applied Anatomy for Students and Junior Doctors by Harold Ellis

Essential Radiological Anatomy for the MRCS

Surgical Critical Care: For the MRCS OSCE by Mazyar Kanani and Simon Lammy

Surgical Critical Care Vivas by Mazyar Kanani

Mcminn’s Color Atlas of Human Anatomy

Netter’s Atlas of Human Anatomy

 

BEST MCQ BOOKS FOR GENERAL SURGERY

Surgery Essence By Pritesh Singh

Surgery Sixer for NBE by Rajamahendran 4th ed (2019)

Bailey & Love Companion Guide Mcqs & Emqs In Surgery

Schwartz’s Principles of Surgery ABSITE and Board Review

Surgery PreTest Self-Assessment and Review, 13th ed

SURGERY COMPLETE – 2019

Surgery For PGMEE 13th Edition – 2019 by Amit Ashish

BEST TEXTBOOKS FOR GENERAL SURGERY

Bailey & Love’s Short Practice of Surgery, 27th Edition

Sabiston’s Textbook of Surgery

Schwartz’s Principles Of Surgery

SRB’S Manual Of Surgery

BEST BOOKS FOR OPERATIVE SURGERY

Operative Techniques in Surgery by Michael W. Mulholland et al

Chassin’s Operative Strategy in General Surgery

Farquharson’s Textbook of Operative General Surgery, 10th Edition

 

World Surgery Forum – Disclaimer
The information given on this page is for educational purposes only and should not be a substitute for professional medical advice. Do not use this information to diagnose or treat your problem without consulting your doctor. This site respects copyright and does not offer any free ebook downloads. The site and posts may contain amazon links of surgery books and products we love.

WorldSurgeryForum.net has been created by a group of Surgeons and Students, just like you. To create the best possible surgery reference and a teaching site, you can help by sharing some of your expertise, experiences, case reports, surgical images and Surgery Youtube videos. By pooling our collective knowledge and experience, we can make a real difference in how people all over the world are managed for various surgical ailments . Every new article, every case, and every image or video counts.

Check out our Social links for regular updates