An open letter to PMO: Trainee Doctors in India have become bonded labourers with no choice of their own (NEET SS Bonds)

4 mn read

NEET SS Bond


To,

The Prime Minister’s Office,
New Delhi
India

Respected Sir,

Subject : Resident Doctor Protection Act for NEET SS counselling 2017.

A general misconception amongst people is that the government is spending whole lot of money in training of postgraduate specialty MS/MD and  super-specialty MCh/DM doctors. But the reality is that a Post graduate or a superspeciality MCH, DM resident doctor (JR/SR) is the backbone for carrying out all the work in any department in a government or a private hospital. Without resident doctors which constitute a cheap labour, it is impossible to run a hospital 24 hours for 7 days a week.

The main purpose of government medical colleges is not only training of doctors but they are mainly tertiary institutes for medical and surgical treatment of poor public. Only a minute fraction of public funds goes towards training of resident doctors which is all taken back as yearly fees, hostel fees, exam fees, library fees etc.

There are actually no training and simulation facilities provided to trainee resident doctors in government medical colleges and they are asked to straight away start on patients from first day of their residency.

Majority of funds put in government hospitals are for patient welfare. There are actually no training and simulation facilities provided to trainee resident doctors in government medical colleges and they are asked to straight away start on patients from first day. So the premise that a lot of money is invested for training postgraduate specialty MS/MD and  super-specialty MCh/DM doctors is not true.

It is the duty of the government to provide a fair opportunity, basic necessities for safe working environment and security of these doctors. At present the following problems are being faced

1. Working hours

There is no prescribed working hours for a resident doctor and hence many doctors are forced to work more than 100 hours in a week. The decision making capacity would begin to decline after long working hours and can have dangerous implications on the health of the patient.

2. Financial insecurity

There has to be a uniform pay for a resident doctor working in any hospital throughout the country. The medical course is long (12 to 15 years) and most resident doctors need to take care of their families and children also. Some colleges are paying a salary of 25000 for a 30 year Senior Resident.

3. Safe working environment

The number of attacks on doctors at hospitals is increasing every day. Many a times it is the lack of infrastructural facilities that is causing problems.

4. Bonds

It takes 16 years to establish as a consultant in medicine. (6 yrs- mbbs + 3 yrs MD/ MS + 3 yrs for DM /Mch + Individual Work Experience ). Some states are imposing a work bond of 5 to 10 years after pursuing a seat in a particular speciality (DM/MCH). By the time a doctor finishes such a course and bond completion of 10 years  he would be 45 years. There is a high possibility that a doctor might die with a heart disease while still pursuing the courses and bonds of the government which are now adding up to 25 to 30 years in total with a fixed meagre pay. They will never get to pursue their own interest in life. These days with so many restrictions on doctors, it is even getting difficult to find a spouse for marriage, as people don’t want to spoil the life of their children by getting them married to a doctor.

Following is the latest status of bonds for superspecialization (DM/MCh) in various states:

  • Delhi – No
  • Punjab- No
  • Haryana- No
  • UP- No
  • Maharashtra- 2 crores/ 1 Year
  • Raj- 25 lakhs/ 5 years
  • MP – No
  • Kerela – 2 crores/ 2 years
  • Karnataka- 50 lakhs/ 3 years
  • TN – 2 crores/ 10 years
  • Gujarat – 50 Laks/ 3 years
  • West Bengal for 3 years, 10 lakhs for each year

5. Hostel facilities

Some colleges do not provide accommodation when joining the course. The conditions of some of these hostels are worst and are poorly maintained. There is no good quality food provided in the mess of some hostels.

Suggested Solutions

Hence I request you to pass a Resident Doctor Protection Act which will uphold the interests of  resident doctors in colleges with following provisions

1. Working Hours. With frame work on maximum permitted working hours per week. Highest permitted straight shifts.( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Medical_resident_work_hours). Guidelines can be based on this article. Working hours should be monitored with biometric system and if doctors are overworked corresponding department and institute should be penalized.

2. One Designation One Pay. The doctor pursuing  Dm/Mch should be given same salary irrespective of college or institute he is working in which should be uniform throughout the country

3. Regulations for Safe working environment and security in the hospitals .

4. In the name of bonds resident doctors are being abused and made to work for 5 to 10 years with a fixed meager pay. Hence de-linking of medical education with bonds has to be done. Any sort of bonds should be abolished. And all existing bonds should be cut down to maximum of 1 year.

5. Provision of hostel facilities, mess with nutritious food and hygenic drinking water at working areas and hostels should be part of mci inspection before giving nod for recognition of courses at all institutes.

Sir in the present scenario many doctors are pledging that they will not let their children take up medicine profession because of the above mentioned difficulties. With NEET superspeciality 2017 admissions happening in the next week if the above mentioned act is passed it will provide security to thousands of doctors to safely pursue their course and provide service to all people in this country. It will inspire the future generation to take medicine as a profession with reassurance.

Thank you


Share this post as much as you can so that our voice is heard.



Some more interesting posts related to Surgery Residency, Surgery NEET SS and DNB SS

EXAM PATTERN AND BOOKS FOR PREPARATION OF SURGERY NEET SS AND DNB SS
https://worldsurgeryforum.net/2017/07/exam-pattern-and-books-for-preparation.html

BEST BOOKS TO READ DURING YOUR GENERAL SURGERY RESIDENCY
https://worldsurgeryforum.net/2017/06/best-books-for-general-surgery-residency.html

Don’t miss these high yield posts and exam guidance by World Surgery Forum. Subscribe Now!

* indicates required

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Explore More Surgery Topics You Like

Best Surgery Books

BEST BOOKS FOR MRCS PART A
MRCS Part A: Essential Revision Notes: Book 1
MRCS Part A: Essential Revision Notes: Book 2

MRCS Practice Papers Part A: Paper 1 SBAs

MRCS Practice Papers Part A: Paper 2 EMQs

Rush University Medical Center Review of Surgery

Bailey & Love Companion Guide Mcqs & Emqs In Surgery

SBA MCQs and EMQs for the MRCS Part A Pack: 2

Basic Science for the MRCS: A revision guide for surgical trainees

Oxford Handbook of Clinical Surgery

Get Through MRCS Part A: SBAs

Mrcs Module 2016 Question With Explanations For Mrcs The Best Question Series

EMQs and Data Interpretation Questions in Surgery

BEST BOOKS FOR MRCS PART B

DrExam Part B MRCS OSCE Revision Guide: Book 1

DrExam Part B MRCS OSCE Revision Guide: Book 2

OSCEs for the MRCS Part B: A Bailey & Love Revision Guide

Succeeding in the MRCS Part B Exam: Essential revision notes for the OSCE format

Get Through MRCS: Anatomy 2E

Clinical Anatomy: Applied Anatomy for Students and Junior Doctors by Harold Ellis

Essential Radiological Anatomy for the MRCS

Surgical Critical Care: For the MRCS OSCE by Mazyar Kanani and Simon Lammy

Surgical Critical Care Vivas by Mazyar Kanani

Mcminn’s Color Atlas of Human Anatomy

Netter’s Atlas of Human Anatomy

 

BEST MCQ BOOKS FOR GENERAL SURGERY

Surgery Essence By Pritesh Singh

Surgery Sixer for NBE by Rajamahendran 4th ed (2019)

Bailey & Love Companion Guide Mcqs & Emqs In Surgery

Schwartz’s Principles of Surgery ABSITE and Board Review

Surgery PreTest Self-Assessment and Review, 13th ed

SURGERY COMPLETE – 2019

Surgery For PGMEE 13th Edition – 2019 by Amit Ashish

BEST TEXTBOOKS FOR GENERAL SURGERY

Bailey & Love’s Short Practice of Surgery, 27th Edition

Sabiston’s Textbook of Surgery

Schwartz’s Principles Of Surgery

SRB’S Manual Of Surgery

BEST BOOKS FOR OPERATIVE SURGERY

Operative Techniques in Surgery by Michael W. Mulholland et al

Chassin’s Operative Strategy in General Surgery

Farquharson’s Textbook of Operative General Surgery, 10th Edition

 

World Surgery Forum – Disclaimer
The information given on this page is for educational purposes only and should not be a substitute for professional medical advice. Do not use this information to diagnose or treat your problem without consulting your doctor. This site respects copyright and does not offer any free ebook downloads. The site and posts may contain amazon links of surgery books and products we love.

WorldSurgeryForum.net has been created by a group of Surgeons and Students, just like you. To create the best possible surgery reference and a teaching site, you can help by sharing some of your expertise, experiences, case reports, surgical images and Surgery Youtube videos. By pooling our collective knowledge and experience, we can make a real difference in how people all over the world are managed for various surgical ailments . Every new article, every case, and every image or video counts.

Check out our Social links for regular updates